Erie same-sex couple married after first judge refuses

by Deb Spilko


A same-sex couple that Senior District Judge Joseph Lefaiver refused to marry were married a week later by Erie 3rd Ward District Judge Tom Carney on Sept. 8, 2014.


Cynthia Baker, 38, and Carrie Ann Loesel, 43, had originally made arrangements with staff at the 5th Ward District office to be married by a judge there. An office staff member said that, as is standard procedure, arrangments were made by staff, including handling of fees. Arrangments were made by phone, and only the surname was taken. When Senior District Judge Joseph Lefaiver realized that this was a same-sex couple, he refused to perform the service, citing personal beliefs. A staff member apologized to the couple and returned the fee. WJET-TV and GoErie covered this story. Lefaiver reportedly refused to comment


District magistrates are not required to perform marriage ceremonies. Lefaiver reportedly has stated he will not be performing any more weddings.